Lancaster Homes with Cape Cod Style

Lancaster Homes with Cape Cod Style

Welcome to Lancaster, Ohio—a charming city nestled in Fairfield County, where historic charm meets modern living. Known for its rich heritage and vibrant community, Lancaster offers a delightful blend of small-town warmth and urban conveniences. With its picturesque streets lined with beautiful trees and well-preserved architecture, this city is a hidden gem that beckons those seeking a serene yet engaging lifestyle.

Lancaster is renowned for its thriving arts scene, highlighted by the Decorative Arts Center of Ohio and the historic Lancaster Festival, which showcases local talent and attracts visitors from near and far. The city is also home to numerous parks and recreational areas, perfect for outdoor enthusiasts and families looking to enjoy nature. With a strong sense of community, residents often gather for local events, farmers' markets, and seasonal celebrations that foster connections and create lasting memories.

If you're captivated by the timeless elegance of Cape Cod-style homes, Lancaster has a selection that will surely enchant you. These charming residences typically feature steeply pitched roofs, symmetrical facades, and cozy interiors that exude warmth and character. The Cape Cod style is perfect for those who appreciate a blend of traditional aesthetics and modern comforts. Many of these homes are situated in quaint neighborhoods, offering a sense of community and proximity to the city's amenities.

Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer or looking to settle into a peaceful retreat, Lancaster’s Cape Cod homes provide an inviting haven to call your own. Discover the allure of Lancaster, where your dream home awaits!

Newest Lancaster Homes with Cape Cod Style

$385,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Zachary T DeLeon
Uniquely designed and impeccably maintained, this retreat-inspired home exhibits delightful contrasts at every turn. All natural materials such as cedar siding and a stone hearth at the wood-burning fireplace blend seamlessly with newer casement windows, an expansive composite deck with cable railing overlooking a creek/ravine, and beautifully updated bathrooms. The loft bedroom suite looks over the warm wood beams and floors of the main level, making every day in this home feel like a getaway. The finished walkout lower level with updated full bath is an unexpected flex space and could be an inviting guest suite, an office or gym, or a second living area. Other updates include roofing (~2017), HVAC (~2019), driveway sealing (2026) and more. Imagine being surrounded by 1.3+/- acres of wooded privacy less than one mile from Fairfield Medical Center and Kroger. This unique home deserves a discerning buyer! See A2A.

1101 Pleasantville Road, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Zachary T DeLeon ---- Keller Williams Greater Cols
$299,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Brock Allen Wagner
Welcome to 356 Edgewood Ave! This updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers a great combination of comfortable living space, modern improvements, and a convenient location. The property includes two parcels, providing additional outdoor space and added possibilities for the next owner. Inside, you'll find an updated kitchen and bathrooms, along with a completely new HVAC system for year-round comfort and peace of mind. The finished basement with egress adds valuable living space with plenty of flexibility for a family room, entertainment area, home office, workout space, or more. Conveniently located near several well-known parks and recreational areas, this home is also just a short distance from U.S. Route 33, providing easy access to shopping, dining, entertainment, and surrounding communities. With major updates already completed, additional finished living space, extra outdoor space, and a convenient location, 356 Edgewood Ave is ready for its next owner. Schedule your private showing today!

356 Edgewood Avenue, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Brock Allen Wagner ---- Anderson & Co. Ohio, LLC
$168,500
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Elizabeth A Fraim
Welcome Home! Classic Cape Cod character meets thoughtful updates at 514 Garfield Avenue. This three-bedroom home offers a comfortable and flexible floor plan with two bedrooms on the main level and an expansive third bedroom upstairs. The large first-floor bedroom could also serve as a family room or home office, while the second main-level bedroom- used as a dining room by the current owners - provides access to the upstairs bedroom and works perfectly for more formal dining, a den or additional living space. The kitchen was updated in 2026, with all kitchen appliances replaced within the past five years, and the inviting family room was refreshed in 2025-2026. Additional improvements include an updated bathroom, updated windows, newer roof and vinyl siding, new water heater in 2017, and a steel chimney liner installed approximately two years ago. Outside, the fenced back yard offers room to relax, garden or play, while the two-car detached garage provides valuable parking and storage. A 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty is also included for added peace of mind.

514 Garfield Avenue, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Elizabeth A Fraim ---- Coldwell Banker Realty
$649,900
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Cindy L Collins
Tucked away at the top of a long private drive, this one-of-a-kind mid-century modern home sits on nearly 6 beautiful wooded acres with incredible views in every direction. It offers an incredible combination of privacy, space, and character. With 5 bedrooms, 3 full and 2 half baths, multiple living areas, and the convenience of first-floor living, there's room here for everyone. Spacious rooms, hardwood floors, sliding barn doors, and thoughtful updates bring together modern style with just the right amount of rustic warmth. And then there's the lower level! Designed for gathering and entertaining, it features a bar area with kegerator, plenty of space for game nights and get-togethers, and one of the home's most unforgettable features- a wine cellar built into the original natural sandstone rock formation. The additional finished space also offers great possibilities for guests, recreation, or multi-generational living. Whether you're enjoying a quiet evening surrounded by the woods or filling the house with family and friends, this is a home that truly stands out. Private, spacious, full of personality, and unlike anything else you'll find on the market.

130 Dogwood Lane, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Cindy L Collins ---- Key Realty
$150,000
1 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Jessica Lee Moyer
ADORABLE doesn't even begin to describe this Lancaster Campgrounds gem! This beautifully remodeled 1-bedroom, 1.5-bath home is packed with character, charm, and thoughtful updates throughout. Step inside to a bright, inviting interior featuring crisp white finishes, beautiful flooring, updated lighting, and an open layout that makes the home feel surprisingly spacious. The updated kitchen offers white cabinetry, modern countertops, stainless steel appliances, stylish gold accents, and plenty of workspace, while flowing easily into the dining and living areas. The large bedroom provides plenty of room to create a comfortable retreat, and having 1.5 baths is an unexpected bonus for a home this size. But the showstopper may just be the incredible covered porch. Stretching along the front of the home, this space feels like an outdoor living room and is absolutely made for morning coffee, relaxing evenings, entertaining friends, or simply enjoying the charm and atmosphere of Lancaster Campgrounds. From the cottage-style exterior and welcoming front entrance to the warm, beautifully finished interior, this home has been transformed into something truly special. Move-in ready, full of personality, and absolutely adorable -- this is one you need to experience in person.

187 9th Street, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Jessica Lee Moyer ---- Realty ONE Group Refined
$450,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Tracey L Dixon
OPEN HOUSE THIS SUNDAY SEPT 6th NOON -2 Welcome home to this charming 2,187 sq. ft. Cape Cod, perfectly situated on a beautiful 2-acre wooded lot offering the privacy and peaceful setting you've been looking for! This spacious home features 3 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, including a desirable first-floor owner's suite with a fully updated private bath featuring a freestanding garden tub, oversized walk-in shower, new flooring and updated fixtures. The open-concept layout flows into the beautifully remodeled kitchen with granite countertops, tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances and a spacious eat-in area. The impressive great room is the heart of the home, featuring towering ceilings, a wood-burning stove and an abundance of natural light. You'll also find a sizable living room, formal dining room and convenient first-floor laundry. Upstairs are two generously sized bedrooms and a newly updated full bath complete with a new vanity, toilet, flooring and fixtures. The large lower level offers plenty of additional space and is ready for your finishing touches, perfect for a future rec room, home gym, office or additional living space. Step outside and enjoy the peaceful wooded surroundings, wrought-iron fenced yard, 16' x 24' concrete patio and beautifully manicured landscaping. Enjoy the best of country living without sacrificing convenience, just 10 minutes from the highway for an easy commute. A wonderful combination of space, privacy, updates and location!

2828 Stoney Hill Road SW, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Tracey L Dixon ---- Keller Williams Greater Cols
$120,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Joanne Denise Hoffmann
Twilight Open House. Thursday September 24th. 5 pm to 7 pm. Take the scenic route on the way home and step into the charm of this 1881 historic cottage in the Lancaster Campground, refreshed with a newly painted board-and-batten exterior. Off-road parking. This inviting home blends classic character with thoughtful modern updates throughout. The kitchen features new; cabinets, stainless-steel sink, laminate countertops, and LVP water-proof flooring. This bright functional space is ready for everyday cooking and weekend hosting. The creation of the new owner's suite completes the lower level. The new bathroom with a stylish barn door features a glass enclosed shower and convenient laundry area. Upstairs, you'll find a spacious bedroom with ample storage. The large closet area includes flex space for a home office or a reading nook. The cozy living room highlights the cottage's original charm with its faux fireplace which provides supplemental gas heat. Comfort is a standout feature with efficient cooling and heat provided by three new mini-splits. The home is filled with natural light offering a relaxing, peaceful atmosphere; a perfect retreat within this historic community. 2026 upgrades include; attic fan, hot water tank, refrigerator and dishwasher. 2025 upgrades; addition of owner's suite, full bath, laundry area and mini-splits. Home Warranty being offered through Home Warranty, INC. for $525

63 Eleventh Street, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Joanne Denise Hoffmann ---- Carleton Realty, LLC
$226,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Dustin Wayne Snyder
Come clucking around here and you will find a 2 BR possible 3rd upstairs Cape Cod with closet on North side of Lancaster that was almost completely rehabbed in 2017; all major appliances are less than 10 years old. Roof put on in October of 2025. Trees removed. Original floors to do with whatever and a clean ready to move in feel. Chicken coop and garden in the back ready for the next little homestead to be. Don't forget the peaceful runoff creek on the outside of the fence that is also a part of the property as it runs through the back side of the lot per the survey from 2023. Seller is a licensed Real Estate Agent in the State of Ohio.

163 N Pershing Drive, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Dustin Wayne Snyder ---- Raymond Realty Group LLC

$279,999
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Zack W Linder
Great opportunity in a quickly appreciating community within walking distance of Historic Downtown Lancaster! Enjoy your spacious 4-bed, 2 bath home with several notable features, Including: A recently renovated kitchen with floor to ceiling cabinets, stainless steel appliances and granite counter tops (2024); Two recently updated first floor full bathrooms (2024); large walkout basement that could easily be finished to add an additional 500+ sq ft of below grade living space; and a sizable back yard with privacy fencing. Bring a few cosmetic updates to unlock this properties full potential and make it your own! Conveniently located only minutes from Downtown Lancaster, Maher Park, Fred's Fine Meats & Cheeses, Talmadge Elementary School & the River Valley Mall. Own your piece of Lancaster today!

328 Reese Avenue, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Zack W Linder ---- Coldwell Banker Realty
$221,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Jeremy D Kirk
Welcome home! This cozy and inviting property offers a wonderful opportunity to move right in and enjoy a long list of thoughtful updates. Recent improvements include a new roof (2018), hot water tank (2021), appliances and disposal (2022), garage system (2022), updated bathroom (2023), grading improvements (2024), fresh interior paint (2025), new outdoor fireplace (2025), fresh mulch (2026), and a freshly sealed driveway (2026). The exterior also features a privacy fence, newer stone trash can area, and an added two-car driveway in the back for convenient off-street parking. The patio creates a great space for relaxing or entertaining, while a detached one-car garage provides additional storage and functionality. Inside, you'll appreciate the flexibility of a first-floor bedroom and office, making the layout ideal for a variety of needs. Conveniently located near the freeway and local amenities, this charming home combines comfort, updates, and convenience. Don't miss the opportunity to make it your own!

1084 Sugar Grove Road SE, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Jeremy D Kirk ---- M3K Real Estate Network Inc.
$99,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Donald E Shaffer
Welcome to this charming & well cared for story and half cottage situated at in the historic Lancaster Camp Ground (Lancaster Camp Meeting Association). Built in the early 1900s, this home offers approximately 936 sq ft of comfortable space, featuring 2 bedrooms, 1 full bathroom, & 5 distinct living spaces filled w/ natural light and timeless character. The functional interior layout offers versatile living and dining areas, a well appointed kitchen, making it perfect for a primary residence or a peaceful weekend getaway, just minutes from downtown Lancaster. The exterior boasts incredible curb appeal with crisp white siding, classic burgundy shutters, delightful flower window boxes, window awnings, and an inviting front entry deck. Nestled among lush, mature shade trees along a paved lane, the property also offers a relaxing side yard setting and a convenient covered side/back porch entrance. Home 1st floor laundry hook-ups (washer and dryer remain), updated kitchen with white appliances included, an updated bath, covered porch, newer flooring, gas & electric heat sources, and window A/C's, & much more. Recent updates include: new kitchen & bath including new plumbing & new electric in 2023. 4 new windows 2026, new paneling & new hot water heater 2024. New gas heater in Living room 2024. Residents take full advantage of exceptional neighborhood amenities, including a large community pool, tennis courts, pickleball courts, a clubhouse, a park, and access to the on-site cafe. Please note that this cottage is situated on leased ground, with a monthly rent/HOA fee that conveniently covers water, sewer, trash, and snow removal. All prospective buyers must obtain formal approval through the Lancaster Campground prior to purchase, and all required association documents and lease information are attached to the listing for your review. Only cash or conventional offers will be considered. Attention Agents: YOU MUST REVIEW AND FOLLOW THE ATA REMARKS. SE

290 14th Street, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Donald E Shaffer ---- Howard HannaRealEstateServices
$429,900
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Jessica L Lawson
Amazing opportunity to own in Lancaster's Brentwood Estates community. Feels like country, but you live in a neighborhood with no HOA. Truly the best of both worlds. This house has open space in the back and is on a dead end street. Very quiet community that is tucked away from the hustle and bustle of Lancaster, but still close enough to enjoy all of the benefits! This property was built in 2018 and has many unique features. 4 bedrooms & 3.5 bathrooms, with not one, but TWO primary suites. One is on the first floor, and another on the second floor. Both have large walk-in closets and full bathrooms. Two more bedrooms on the second floor round out the total of 4 bedrooms. Upstairs there is another full bath for the two bedrooms to share access. The living space has cathedral, open ceilings and lets in tons of natural light throughout the home. The living space flows right into the open kitchen with an island and eat-in space. Down the hall is the basement access, garage access, laundry room, half bath and access to the first floor primary suite. The basement is full with tall ceiling space, and ready to be transformed into a huge living space. Rough in for a bath located in the basement. So much opportunity here!

1751 Declaration Drive W, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Jessica L Lawson ---- Revolution Realty LLC
Start Your Search