Refine Search
Map
Sort by
$1,300,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Susan Chapman
Welcome to Buckeye Lake! This fabulous property offers 69 feet of prime water frontage, 3,780 sq ft of living space and was designed for entertaining! Upon entering your living room you can enjoy the lake views from your wall of windows with custom automatic blinds. This three bedroom home has two gourmet kitchens with sleek countertops, gas stoves and stainless steel appliances. The spa like full bath has an oversized walk-in tile shower. The dining room is located off the kitchen with sliding glass doors leading to your composite deck with a pergola and sunsetter sun shade. The lower level offers a rec room, full kitchen and a full bath. The spacious backyard is privacy fenced in with an electric gate, paver fire pit, mature trees, basketball hoop, and a patio area. If offers a safe space for pets and children. This property is on two parcels. Be prepared to be impressed by the approx 50x60 Carriage House located in the rear. It offers a true RV bay with electric and water. There are radiant heated floors and radiant concrete on the exterior pad also. Located in the building, is a first floor full bath and a three car bay for up to 6 cars, your boat and/or water toys. Upstairs there is an approx 1700 square ft luxury guest quarters that is perfect for overnight guests, an in law suite, or multigenerational living. The soapstone counter tops, marble vanities, and white oak floors are just a few of the many exquisite details. The dock located in the front has space for two boats. Enjoy easy access to the lake's 4.1 mile walking/biking path, which offers breathtaking views of the lake, the dam & surrounding natural beauty!

13474 W Bank Drive NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Susan Chapman ---- Keller Williams Greater Cols

Selling Office: Key Realty.

$925,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Brian D Kemp
Welcome to 'The Perfect Tack,' a custom-built, 3,864 sq ft waterfront home designed for both luxury and comfort. Located at 4255 Northbank Road NE, this stunning retreat offers a serene escape in Fairfield County's Walnut Township. Step outside to the scenic bike / walking path and enjoy the beauty and serenity of this unique 4.1 mile promenade. Highlights of this exceptional home include: Elevated Living: A private, 4-stop elevator provides seamless access to all three levels. Spacious & Thoughtful Design: This home features 5 bedrooms, 3 full and 2 half baths, and elegant Brazilian Cherry hardwood floors on the main level. Gourmet Kitchen: The chef's kitchen boasts granite countertops and a breakfast bar, perfect for gathering with family and friends. Entertaining Made Easy: The upper-level great room includes a custom Buckeye Lake-themed wet bar, while the covered porch and covered balcony offer year-round enjoyment with built-in speakers and ceiling fans. Independent Guest Suite: A private 630 sq ft guest or in-law suite with its own kitchen, living room, full bath, and laundry provides a perfect space for visitors or multi-generational living. Oversized Garage: The massive 4-car garage features a 13' ceiling and a 10' overhead door, making it ideal for storing an RV, boat, or for use as a workshop. Ready for Your Dock: The state-issued dock pad is ready for you to create your own custom lakeside dock. This rare opportunity blends sophisticated design with practical living. With high-efficiency mechanical systems, city utilities, and a prewired security and internet systems, this home offers elevated lake living, modern conveniences, and complete peace of mind.

4255 N Bank Road NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Brian D Kemp ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs

Selling Office: Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs.

$680,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Lindsay Higgins
Experience true lakefront living at Buckeye Lake in this meticulously maintained log-style home offering direct water access and panoramic main-lake views. The property features an expansive wood deck with built-in fire pit and seating area at the water's edge, a covered porch, and an upper-level balcony—all positioned to take in open water and horizon views. The partially fenced yard (new 2024) and wide concrete drive provide secure space for parking boats, golf carts, and guests. Inside, the open-concept layout connects the kitchen, dining, and living areas with water views from nearly every angle. A main-level bedroom and full bath provide flexible living, while the upper level adds additional bedrooms and sleeping space. Extensive recent updates include new roof, fence, and hot water tank (2024), full log maintenance and stain (2025), driveway replacement (2018), whole-house generator (2020), and seawall with steel-beam dock construction (2019). HVAC systems are modernized (AC ~7 yrs old, furnace <5 yrs). Located minutes from Buckeye Lake's most popular destinations—Horvath's Harbor (1.1 mi), The Port Smokehouse (2.2 mi), and Buckeye Lake Winery (3.4 mi)—this property blends timeless log-cabin charm with today's functional upgrades. Ideal for year-round living, weekend retreats, or short-term vacation rental investment. Includes ample storage in the attached 2-car garage and easy access to SR-13 and I-70 for commutes to Columbus or Newark. Video available online for virtual viewing.

10800 Honey Creek Road, Thornville

Listing Courtesy of : Lindsay Higgins ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs

Selling Office: Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs.

$535,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Stefani J Price
Welcome to this truly immaculate home, ideally located just minutes from Buckeye Lake while offering the peaceful country setting you've been dreaming about. Situated on four parcels, this unique property offers incredible flexibility and room to grow. The home and impressive 32x48 outbuilding sit on one parcel, while three additional parcels provide endless opportunities for future expansion, additional structures, recreation, or simply enjoying extra space and privacy. From the moment you arrive, it's clear that no corners were cut. The current owners have invested extensively in both the beauty and functionality of the property, creating a home that is as well-maintained as it is charming. Thoughtful updates include a beautifully remodeled first-floor bathroom, custom oak staircase with steel balusters, updated kitchen appliances, custom lighting, newer flooring, fresh paint, a new front door, Trane HVAC system with new ductwork, city water hookup, water softener, water heater, concrete driveway, sump pump system, and much more. Every improvement reflects pride of ownership and attention to detail. The home currently offers 2 bedrooms plus a loft, but the opportunities here extend far beyond the existing footprint. The impressive 32x48 outbuilding offers exceptional flexibility for storage, hobbies, recreational vehicles, or workshop space. Located just a minute from Buckeye Lake, it's ideal for boat storage, making it easy to enjoy lake life without sacrificing space at home. Whether you're a boating enthusiast, car collector, hobbyist, or simply need extra storage and workspace, this versatile building is ready to fit your needs. Outside you'll enjoy a newer deck, whole house generator, welcoming front porch, mature landscaping, and plenty of room to relax, entertain, and enjoy the beauty of the surrounding countryside. A rare opportunity to enjoy a peaceful country setting, modern updates, and room to grow--all just a minute from Buckeye Lake!

13525 Newark Drive NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Stefani J Price ---- Cutler Real Estate

Selling Office: Red 1 Realty.

$423,000
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Courtney C Wilson
PRICE IMPROVEMENT! Lake life is calling! &#127749; Escape to this beautiful 5-bedroom, 2-bath home right on Buckeye Lake. Enjoy stunning waterfront views, plenty of space for family and friends, and your very own private dock--perfect for boating, fishing, and sunset evenings by the water. Offering 2,185 sq ft of living space, this home blends farmhouse charm with modern living. An addition completed in 1999 adds extra room to spread out and enjoy lake life. Relax on the screened-in front porch and take in the peaceful surroundings. Located within walking distance to Weldon's Ice Cream, Millersport Coffee, the famous Millersport Sweet Corn Festival, and several hometown restaurants--this location truly captures the charm of the community. The home features an attached 2-car garage and plenty of additional parking on the oversized concrete driveway. Inside, you'll find a first-floor primary bedroom with a full bathroom that includes a soaking tub and plenty of cabinet space, along with convenient first-floor laundry. The open floor plan flows into a large kitchen complete with a kitchen island--perfect for entertaining. Recent updates include: • New A/C (2020) • Furnace (2023) • Roof (2025) • Insulation (2025). Whether you're looking for a weekend getaway or a full-time lake retreat, this home offers the perfect blend of relaxation and adventure. Message me for details or to schedule a showing! &#128676;

2595 Canal Drive, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Courtney C Wilson ---- RE/MAX 360

Selling Office: Irongate Inc..

$397,500
⋅ Stefani J Price
Incredible opportunity to build your dream home on Buckeye Lake! Tucked away in one of the lake's best-kept secrets, this beautiful pocket of homes offers the perfect setting for your custom build. Enjoy peaceful surroundings, scenic views, and a true sense of community among neighboring waterfront estates. This rare .21-acre waterfront lot features approx. 150' (+/-) of water frontage on a deep canal just west of Heron Bay, offering quick access to the main lake. Includes a private dock with aluminum sea wall, 3 oversized slips (2 covered- 1 with electric boat lift- & 1 uncovered, 2covered jet ski pads remaining), and a charming boathouse with new black aluminum roof, white siding, and a freshly finished interior with electric. A cozy fire pit area adds the perfect touch for relaxing evenings by the water. Utilities in place—electric & water on site, sewer available. Recent updates include new roof & siding, interior walls, insulation, lighting, flooring, cabinets, countertop, landscaping, fire pit, ski lifts & gravel driveway.

15172 N Canoe Lane, Thornville

Listing Courtesy of : Stefani J Price ---- Cutler Real Estate

Selling Office: Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs.

$365,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Sam Cooper
Welcome to your brand-new retreat near Buckeye Lake! This is located just blocks from the lake, offering the ideal escape for weekend getaways, seasonal living, or a low-maintenance vacation home as well as comfortable home located just off rout 70 for easy access to anywhere. Designed with relaxation and entertaining in mind, the home features vaulted ceilings and a bright open-concept layout that seamlessly connects the living, dining, and kitchen areas. Natural light pours in, highlighting the modern finishes and quality craftsmanship throughout—everything you want in a new build with none of the upkeep concerns. Step outside to the covered front porch, the perfect spot to enjoy morning coffee or unwind after a day on the water. With boating, dining, and lake activities just a short walk away, this home captures the essence of easy Buckeye Lake living. Whether you're searching for a personal vacation getaway, a second home, or a weekend retreat near the water, this newly built property offers comfort, convenience, and location—all in one. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a new home just minutes from Buckeye Lake.

83 Seymour Avenue, Buckeye Lake

Listing Courtesy of : Sam Cooper ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs

Selling Office: RE/MAX Partners.

$285,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Brian D Kemp
Welcome to this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch offering 1,650 square feet of comfortable living near beautiful Buckeye Lake. The inviting open floor plan features a vaulted great room with a ceiling fan/light fixture and a cozy corner wood-burning fireplace with a brick hearth and mantel — perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The kitchen includes an island, subway tile backsplash, and plenty of cabinet space for all your cooking needs. Enjoy the convenience of first-floor laundry and a spacious deck for outdoor gatherings. Each bedroom includes an overhead light fixture, with two featuring ceiling fans for added comfort. A 2-car detached garage provides ample storage and parking. This home blends style, comfort, and functionality in a desirable lake community setting.

3621 S Bank Road NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Brian D Kemp ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs

Selling Office: RE/MAX ONE.

$260,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Shauna L Brennan
BEAUTIFULLY UPDATED BUCKEYE LAKE HOME W/ MAIN LAKE WATER VIEWS!!! Steps to the Lake! Modern Updates Throughout. New LVT Hardwood Floors. Updated Kitchen w/ White Cabinets & New Counters. Large Living Room w/ Cozy Gas Fireplace. Master Suite has Walk-in Closet & Bath. 2 Additional Bedrooms. 1st Floor Laundry (Washer/Dryer can Remain). Massive Deck perfect for Additional Living Space. Sprawling Fenced Rear Yard w/ Poured Patio & Additional Deck. Oversized 2 Car Garage. New Roof (2021). New Furnace (2024). H2O Tank (Approx 9 Years). Home Generator. Walking Distance to Downtown Millersport w/ Many Restaurants & Shops, Buckeye Lake Marina and Weldon's Ice Cream. 2 Parcels, See A2A Remarks

12176 Bright Street NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Shauna L Brennan ---- RE/MAX ONE

Selling Office: RE/MAX ONE.