Carroll Homes for Sale

Carroll Homes for Sale

Welcome to Carroll, Ohio – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Fairfield County. Known for its charming small-town atmosphere and welcoming community, Carroll is the perfect place for those seeking a peaceful yet vibrant lifestyle. With its picturesque landscapes and rich history, this quaint city offers a unique blend of suburban comfort and rural charm, making it an ideal setting for families, retirees, and everyone in between.

Carroll boasts an array of local amenities, including parks, shops, and dining options that cater to all tastes. Enjoy leisurely strolls through the lush green spaces or partake in community events that foster a strong sense of belonging. The area's excellent schools and family-friendly environment make it a top choice for those looking to settle down.

For those in the market for a new home, Carroll presents a diverse selection of properties for sale. From cozy single-family homes with spacious yards to modern townhouses perfect for first-time buyers, there’s something here for everyone. Many homes in Carroll feature beautiful architectural details, updated interiors, and easy access to local amenities, ensuring that you’ll find a property that suits your lifestyle.

As you explore the homes for sale in Carroll, you’ll discover a community that values quality of life and a strong sense of connection. Whether you’re looking to buy your first home or seeking a tranquil retreat, Carroll, Ohio, is ready to welcome you home. Don’t miss the opportunity to become part of this wonderful community!

Newest Carroll Homes for Sale

$450,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Amanda Herman
Set on a beautiful 5.01 acre parcel in the Bloom Carroll Local School District, this spacious ranch offers room to live, gather, and grow. The home features four bedrooms, two full bathrooms, a comfortable living room, and a separate family room with direct access to the backyard. The bright, spacious kitchen offers abundant cabinetry, generous counter space, and a skylight that fills the room with natural light. The owner's suite provides a relaxing retreat with a private bathroom featuring a double vanity, soaking tub, and walk in shower. A full basement adds tremendous potential and includes exterior walkup access, a finished room that could serve as a fifth bedroom, office, or hobby room, plus a unique safe room or hidden room. The remaining space is a blank canvas ready to be finished to suit your needs. A breezeway provides covered access to the attached two car garage. Outside, enjoy expansive green space, mature trees, a basketball court, and a rear patio with space for outdoor seating and a firepit. Whether enjoying coffee in the morning, entertaining guests, or simply appreciating the peaceful country setting, this property offers acreage, versatility, and endless possibilities. Major improvements include a roof that is approximately two years old with no second layer, air conditioning and an electric hot water tank that are approximately five years old, windows that are approximately 10 years old, and a sump pump installed approximately one month ago. The home also features an electric furnace and a water filtration system. With 5.01 acres, flexible living areas, valuable mechanical updates, and room to create the lifestyle you have been envisioning, this property offers space, versatility, and endless possibilities.

3890 Carroll Eastern Road NW, Carroll

Listing Courtesy of : Amanda Herman ---- Realty ONE Group Refined
$399,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Elizabeth Warthman
Showings start September 23, 2026! Enjoy comfortable country living in this ranch home situated on 1.16 acres. The main level offers 3 bedrooms, 1.5 baths and a beautifully remodeled kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances, updated cabinetry and a pantry. Approximately 600 square feet of finished lower-level space provides a fourth bedroom and plenty of room for a family room, home office or hobby area. The walkout basement also includes the laundry area, and the washer and dryer remain. Outside, enjoy the large deck, an oversized 2-car attached garage and an additional 24x30 detached garage--ideal for extra vehicles, equipment, storage or a workshop. Conveniently located in the Bloom-Carroll School district with space both inside and out!

4422 Kauffman Road NW, Carroll

Listing Courtesy of : Elizabeth Warthman ---- Key Realty
$1,250,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Isabella Mae Knecht
Welcome to this incredible 54.5-acre property located in the highly desirable Bloom-Carroll Local School District. Offering privacy, space, and beautiful country views, this property has so much to offer. The spacious home features 5 generously sized bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, a walkout basement, home gym, and plenty of room for everyday living and entertaining. Outside, you'll find a large barn complete with 5 horse stalls, ample storage, and an impressive party room with its own bar perfect for hosting friends and family. The property features a beautiful ravine, scenic views, and plenty of acreage to enjoy whether you're looking for an equestrian property, private country retreat, or simply room to spread out. A truly unique opportunity in Bloom-Carroll Schools!

6590 Lithopolis Road, Carroll

Listing Courtesy of : Isabella Mae Knecht ---- RE/MAX Revealty
$485,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Caroline C Shroyer
If space is what you're looking for, this one delivers! Situated on 1.5 acres in a cul-de-sac, this spacious 4-level split offers room to spread out both inside and out. The main level features a formal living room and an eat-in kitchen with granite countertops and stainless steel appliances. Three bedrooms are located upstairs, with a fourth bedroom on the lower level, along with a family room and den. Two full bathrooms provide added convenience. Fresh paint and new carpet add a fresh feel. AC/Heat Pump 8/2025. Hot water heater 10/2023. Kinetico water softener and Reverse Osmosis 11/2020. A large front porch welcomes you in, while the expansive back porch overlooks the beautiful backyard setting. With a 4-car attached garage plus a 2-car detached garage/building, there is plenty of room for vehicles, hobbies, storage and more. Spend summer evenings gathered around the firepit, enjoying the peaceful setting and maybe a s'more or two. If you're looking for space, beauty, comfort and the freedom to enjoy it all, this could be the one you've been waiting for!

4465 Pine Hills Court NW, Carroll

Listing Courtesy of : Caroline C Shroyer ---- Keller Williams Consultants
$644,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Grant Huthmaker
Custom Home in Bloom-Carroll School District Nestled on a private, wooded 1.94-acre lot, this custom-built 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers the space, quality, and character that production builders can't match. Inside, hardwood floors are complemented by custom woodwork and trim details found in every room. Soaring 9-foot ceilings add to the open, airy feel, while the cozy gas fireplace anchors the living space for those cooler evenings. Outside, enjoy morning coffee or evening sunsets from either the covered front porch or covered back porch, both perfect for taking in the tree-line surrounding. The oversized 2-car garage provides ample room for vehicles, tools, and storage. There is additional storage in the finished attic area. Located in the sought-after Bloom-Carroll School District, this one-of-a-kind property combines custom craftsmanship with privacy and space -- a rare find close to Lancaster. 4 Bed | 2.5 Bath | 1.94 Wooded Acres | Bloom-Carroll Schools

3588 Havensport Road NW, Carroll

Listing Courtesy of : Grant Huthmaker ---- BARTLETT BENNER REALTY
$878,500
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Hasina Nelson
Unique opportunity to own approximately 2.5 acres in the Pickerington Local School District! Built in 2017, this custom sprawling ranch offers over 3,000 sq. ft. on the main level, plus approximately 2,000 sq. ft. of additional finished living space in the professionally finished basement completed in 2024--bringing the home to approximately 5,000 sq. ft. of living space! The open floor plan features a foyer overlooking a private den/home office and large formal dining room. The stunning great room offers soaring ceilings, a beautiful fireplace and custom finishes. The gorgeous kitchen features upgraded cabinetry, granite countertops, backsplash, updated fixtures, new stainless steel appliances in 2026 and a spacious eating area. The main level also offers generously sized bedrooms and bathrooms, first-floor laundry with plenty of cabinetry and storage, a half bath and 3-car garage. The owner's suite is a true retreat with an impressive walk-in closet, tiled shower and double sinks. The expansive finished basement features two additional bedrooms, full bath, living/rec room, playroom and a unique hidden bonus room tucked behind a bookcase, plus an egress window--ideal for entertaining, guests, working from home or multigenerational living. Outside, enjoy a fenced backyard, patio and an incredible 40x64 outbuilding with concrete floors and electric. Permanent exterior lighting along the roofline and inside the fenced area can be customized through an app with different colors, animations and lighting designs for year-round enjoyment. Additional features include a tankless water heater and water softener. Enjoy the peace, privacy and stars at night while still being conveniently located near highways, restaurants, schools and parks! Schedule your showing today! Agents please see Agent to Agent.

6548 Basil Western Road NW, Carroll

Listing Courtesy of : Hasina Nelson ---- Keller Williams Greater Cols
$360,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Anne M Nossaman
COUNTRY LIVING with the convenience of being close to the city in this recently updated 2 bedroom, 2 bath home. Surrounded by beautiful fields, the property offers a peaceful and convenient setting, along with a fenced in backyard, 2 detached garages, and a NEWER HVAC system installed in 2025. It is the perfect blend of country tranquility and easy access to city amenities. Close to Route 33, 270, 23, 71, Pickerington, Buckeye Lake, Lancaster and more. Additional updates include: NEW water heater in 2025, furnace and heat pump new in 2025, water softener new in 2025, and all kitchen appliances new in 2025. Schedule your private showing today.

6135 Allen Road, Carroll

Listing Courtesy of : Anne M Nossaman ---- Parker Realty Associates
$325,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Holli Renaye Jones
Welcome home to this warm and inviting property in the heart of Carroll, Ohio, where comfort, character, and a welcoming atmosphere come together. Step inside through the enclosed front porch, the perfect place to settle in with a cup of hot chocolate and enjoy the changing seasons. The cozy living room features a gas fireplace, creating a warm gathering space for relaxing evenings, movie nights, and making memories as the cooler weather arrives. The main-floor primary bedroom offers everyday convenience and privacy, complete with a walk-in closet. The home features 2 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, plus a versatile den currently being used as a third bedroom. Whether you need a bedroom, home office, reading room, or extra space for guests, this area offers wonderful flexibility and the potential for a third bedroom. The large, beautiful back deck provides a peaceful place to enjoy your morning coffee, watch the sunset, unwind after a long day, or gather with friends and family. The above-ground pool is ready for summer enjoyment, while a detached 2-car garage adds valuable storage and workspace, giving you room for vehicles, outdoor equipment, hobbies, or whatever your needs may be. With its cozy fireplace, enclosed porch, main-floor primary bedroom, flexible living space, and inviting outdoor areas, this Carroll home has the kind of comfortable feel that makes you want to stay awhile. Added bonus this home is already tapped into the village's new mandatory sewer system. Come take a look and see if this cozy Carroll home is the place you have been looking for!

70 Highland Street, Carroll

Listing Courtesy of : Holli Renaye Jones ---- Realty ONE Group Refined
$189,900
⋅ Kelly Abbott
BUILD YOUR DREAM HOME ON THIS AMAZING 2.07 ACRE LOT!

7221 Pebble Creek Drive NW Lot 44 Unit Lot 44, Carroll

Listing Courtesy of : Kelly Abbott ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs
$169,900
⋅ Kelly Abbott
BUILD YOUR DREAM HOME ON THIS 2.02 ACRE LOT! AMAZING!

4312 Stone Hill Drive W Lot 46 Unit Lot 46, Carroll

Listing Courtesy of : Kelly Abbott ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs
$179,900
⋅ Kelly Abbott
BUILD YOUR DREAM HOME ON THIS STUNNING, 2.02 ACRE LOT!

4138 Stone Hill Drive E Lot 27 Unit Lot 27, Carroll

Listing Courtesy of : Kelly Abbott ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs
$649,999
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Damien Van Horn
It's so easy to fall in love with this brand new custom construction home built by America's Home Place. See the documents section for the complete list of features on this beautiful ranch style home with 3 bedrooms 2 full bathrooms, and easy one floor living on 2 acres of land. Enjoy all new everything with room to grow! Bloom Carroll schools. Schedule your showing today.

5819 Basil Western Road NW, Carroll

Listing Courtesy of : Damien Van Horn ---- Coldwell Banker Realty
Start Your Search