Sugar Grove Homes under $400,000

Sugar Grove Homes under $400,000

Welcome to Sugar Grove, Ohio—a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Fairfield County. Known for its picturesque landscapes and a warm, welcoming community, Sugar Grove offers a tranquil lifestyle while being conveniently located near the bustling cities of Columbus and Lancaster. The charm of this quaint village is evident in its lush parks, friendly neighborhoods, and a strong sense of community spirit.

For those seeking a beautiful home without breaking the bank, Sugar Grove is the perfect destination. The real estate market here boasts an impressive selection of homes priced under $400,000. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, a growing family, or looking to downsize, you’ll find a diverse array of properties that cater to various tastes and needs. From charming single-family homes with spacious yards to cozy ranch-style houses ideal for easy living, there’s something for everyone in this delightful town.

The affordability of homes in Sugar Grove does not compromise quality. Many properties feature modern amenities, open floor plans, and beautiful outdoor spaces, perfect for entertaining or enjoying peaceful evenings under the stars. The local school district is highly regarded, making it an attractive option for families.

In addition to its appealing homes, Sugar Grove offers a variety of recreational activities, including hiking trails, local shops, and community events that bring neighbors together. Embrace the charm of Sugar Grove, where your dream home awaits at an affordable price! Come and experience the perfect blend of small-town charm and modern living today.

Newest Sugar Grove Homes under $400,000

219 Maple Street, Sugar Grove
$244,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Michelle Ross
If you have been looking for a home in the Berne Union School District or close to 33, this two-story is ready for its next owner. From the street, the covered front porch welcomes you right inside. Throughout the main level, updates include flooring, fresh paint, fixtures, and a full bath with a shower/tub combo. The large dining room is right off the kitchen featuring new cabinets, a massive center island, appliances, and a deep pantry area. The second floor offers 3 bedrooms with new paint and carpet, including a primary suite with a full bathroom. For added convenience, the laundry area is located beside the back door that takes you out onto the newly surfaced covered deck that leads to the partially fenced-in yard. A detached 1-car garage finishes off the property, giving you off-street parking or extra storage.

219 Maple Street, Sugar Grove

Listing Courtesy of : Michelle Ross ---- Rise Realty
SE Taos Lane, Sugar Grove
$150,000
⋅ Kelly J Brohard
Discover a rare opportunity to own 2.5 beautiful, buildable acres within the gated Hide-A-Way Hills community. Offering a wonderful blend of privacy, mature trees and partially level areas, this property provides an inviting setting for your future home or weekend retreat. Conveniently located near the Borah Hill gate, you'll enjoy easy access in and out of the community while still feeling peacefully tucked away in nature. Bring your plans and imagine the possibilities, all while enjoying the lakes, golf course, pool, Lodge and countless recreational amenities Hide-A-Way Hills offers.

SE Taos Lane, Sugar Grove

Listing Courtesy of : Kelly J Brohard ---- Sorrell & Company, Inc.
2510 Pump Station Road SE, Sugar Grove
$264,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Natalie Mesler
Back on the Market - no fault of the sellers! Discover the perfect blend of space, updates and rural privacy in this inviting 3-bedroom, 1-bath home situated on approximately .75 acres in Berne Union School District. The home features a full unfinished basement with plumbing in place for a future full bathroom, lower-level laundry area and additional storage or living space potential. Recent updates include a furnace installed in 2026, well pressure tank replaced in 2024, luxury vinyl plank flooring in 2023, exterior siding repainted and bathroom updated in 2022. Kitchen was remodeled and new stainless steel appliances in 2020. Roof was replaced in 2018. Additional features include natural gas, gas stove, water softener, and gravel pad for camper or additional parking. The property includes a shared driveway and easement - buyers are encouraged to verify recorded terms. Washer and dryer to convey. Home is being sold As-Is.

2510 Pump Station Road SE, Sugar Grove

Listing Courtesy of : Natalie Mesler ---- Rock House Realty LLC
313 N Main Street, Sugar Grove
$269,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Angela L Keener
Motivated Seller relocated out of state, here is your chance to buy a move in a ready home! New Carpet and fresh paint. Ideal location, close to schools. Enjoy the covered porch and the quiet small-town atmosphere. Walk inside to find many updates. 2-staircases lead to 4 bedrooms, one staircase leads to a large private primary bedroom. Includes a full bath on the first and 2nd level for your convenience. This updated 1900 home has the charm of large spacious rooms and high ceilings. Fenced backyard with large barn and many perennials to enjoy. There is so much more to see, make your appointment today!

313 N Main Street, Sugar Grove

Listing Courtesy of : Angela L Keener ---- Keller Williams Consultants
191 Apache Lane, Sugar Grove
$349,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Kyle L Walker
Escape to the woods at 191 Apache Lane, a welcoming retreat set on two lots along a quiet cul-de-sac, with access to resort amenities. A wide front porch sets the tone for relaxed living, while the expansive rear deck offers covered and open spaces for morning coffee, outdoor dining, and unwinding above scenic wooded ravines. Inside, the great room pairs a soaring beamed wood ceiling with warm pine flooring and a striking stone-surround fireplace. Large windows and multiple sliding doors frame the wooded surroundings and connect the living spaces to the deck. The bright kitchen features white cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, a subway tile backsplash, and breakfast bar seating, opening to a corner dining area with forest views. A spacious bedroom and full bath complete the main level. A spiral staircase leads to the walkout lower level, offering a recreation area along with a second bedroom with second fireplace that could be used as a flexible space for hobbies and a second full bath with ample storage. Enjoy peaceful days at home or take advantage of the community's resort amenities this woodland retreat brings relaxation and recreation together.

191 Apache Lane, Sugar Grove

Listing Courtesy of : Kyle L Walker ---- Walker Tiu Real Estate Group
676 Natchez Lane, Sugar Grove
$299,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Christopher V Flores
Unique Lake & Golf Course Home in Hideaway Hills Club This special 1969 summer resort home sits on a half-acre lake overlook lot (Lot 676) overlooking the Lake of Four Seasons, with the 9-hole golf course directly behind it on Hole #4. Every evening, the expansive front porch offers stunning sunset views over the lake. Mature trees growing through the porch create a magical treehouse-meets-Lakehouse atmosphere, while the home's clever design captures a wonderful natural breeze that keeps the house cool under a canopy of trees. Inside, you'll find approximately 1,702 sq ft of living space with reclaimed hardwood floors, walls of windows, a large open kitchen, vaulted living room ceilings, 3 bedrooms, and 3 full baths. The master suite opens to a spacious loft that connects directly to the second bedroom. Recently updated and fully winterized for year-round living, it features a serviced heat pump and central air, a private well with exceptionally sweet water, and a recently serviced septic system. A friendly herd of deer frequently gathers under the porch, adding to the peaceful setting. Located in the private, gated Hideaway Hills Club, the low $257 monthly HOA fee covers all road maintenance, snow plowing, full security team, and maintenance crew, while giving you access to an impressive list of amenities including five lakes, golf course with clubhouse, pool, tennis & pickleball courts, fitness center, shooting range, organic garden, horse barn, frisbee golf, amphitheater, chapel in the pines, and the lodge with its own brewery. This is true lakeside living in a wonderful, friendly community.

676 Natchez Lane, Sugar Grove

Listing Courtesy of : Christopher V Flores ---- Century 21 HomeStar
1765 Mohican Court, Sugar Grove
$349,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Tammy J Gordon
Nestled on nearly 1.5 wooded acres in Hide-A-Way Hills, this private well maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath cabin offers the perfect retreat surrounded by nature. Features include walls of windows, a remodeled kitchen, custom wood staircase, screened porch, shed, covered front porch with cedar posts, and two rebuilt/extended decks. First floor offers open concept with kitchen, living and dining space w/wood burning stove and full bath. Upstairs you will find a loft, 3 bedrooms, balcony deck, full bath and laundry. Outside offers deck and acess to a screened porch w/hot tub electric hookup. Great yard w/fire pit and several spots perfect for adding a detached garage. Additonal updates include roof (2016), furnace & heat pump (2017), breaker panel (2018), tankless water heater, reverse osmosis system, water softener, updated lighting, new entry doors with keyless entry, exterior paint, gutter guards, and perimeter drainage. Enjoy all Hide-A-Way Hills amenities including 24-hour gated security, lakes, golf, pool, beach, clubhouse, lodge, brewery, fitness center and more.

1765 Mohican Court, Sugar Grove

Listing Courtesy of : Tammy J Gordon ---- Keller Williams Greater Cols
701 Natchez Lane, Sugar Grove
$285,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Jodi E Bird
Welcome home to your cozy cabin on nearly 1.5 acres. Interior cedar walls, original hardwood floors, a rounded corner fireplace and a large, covered deck are just some of the features this house has to offer. Large picture windows allow plenty of natural sunlight to filter throughout the A-frame structure. Gorgeous views of the lake and towering trees can be seen from the living room, the loft area, or even from the upper trails that meander through the additional acre behind the home. An upper deck and lower deck add ideal outdoor living space to entertain or to just relax. Inside you'll enjoy a total of three bedrooms and two full baths located between the two stories. Square footage is efficiently laid out with a full dining area off of the kitchen. An office or reading nook can easily be set up downstairs by the living room or upstairs in the loft area. The basement is roomy enough to have a nice workshop area with direct access to the lower deck. Cement driveway was installed this spring as was a new split system. Hide-A-Ways Hills Resort is an outdoor playground with tennis & pickleball courts, a swimming pool, a golf course, lakes to utilize both your boat and kayaks, a disc golf course, shooting range, stables, and ATV trails. Connect with the community through services at the outdoor chapel, over a meal/drink at the lodge/bar or during many of the social events held regularly such as the summer concert series at the amphitheater. Everyday gorgeous views of the lake can be seen through the trees.

701 Natchez Lane, Sugar Grove

Listing Courtesy of : Jodi E Bird ---- Howard HannaRealEstateServices
36 Seneca Lane, Sugar Grove
$329,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Amy Wright
Welcome to this charming home nestled in the desirable Hide-A-Way Hills community. Situated on a beautifully wooded 1.99-acre lot, this property offers the perfect blend of privacy and resort-style living within a gated HOA. Inside you'll find 2 bedrooms and 1.5 bath with a functional layout. The large living room serves as the heart of the home, highlighted by a cozy pellet stove that creates a warm and inviting space. In the kitchen you will find a new electric range and microwave to add to the already established kitchen appliances. Other amenities include a sunroom, walk in closet, attached 2 car garage plus a large deck for outdoor entertaining & cookouts. This home offers access to lakes, trails and outdoor recreation - making it a perfect escape for nature lovers.

36 Seneca Lane, Sugar Grove

Listing Courtesy of : Amy Wright ---- SAYRE SEALS & MCMILLAN REAL ESTATE LLC
474 Natchez Lane, Sugar Grove
$259,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Jeff Shaw
Offered at $289,900, this prime double lot home is ideally positioned on the golf course within a desirable Hide Away Hills gated lake community. Located within minutes of the clubhouse and lodge, this is an exceptional opportunity where modest improvements could create significant value. This 3 bedroom 2 full bath home with extensive decking for outdoor living offers incredible potential as a full time residence or weekend retreat. You will have access to the resort community's exceptional amenities, including: 4 lakes for boating, paddle boarding, swimming and fishing, 9 hole golf course with Clubhouse, Lodge with bar / restaurant, community swimming pool, tennis , pickle ball courts, fitness center, shooting range, outdoor chapel, outdoor Amphitheatre with summer concert series, ATV trails, shooting range and 24/7 Security.

474 Natchez Lane, Sugar Grove

Listing Courtesy of : Jeff Shaw ---- Sorrell & Company, Inc.
Start Your Search